No One Plays It Anymore, It's Too Popular
Written Oct. 9, 2009 by Sean Ross in Content + Research + Terrestrial Radio with 2 Comments
Over the last year or so, I've noticed a few of the Classic Rock format's most reliable songs finally starting to look just a little golden -- warhorses where burn is starting to rival preference, or even drive it down after many years.
But not "Stairway To Heaven." It shows some burn, but not enough to push it out of its customary place in the top five.
And why is "Stairway To Heaven" avoiding the fate of some of its contemporaries? At least in part because it gets so much less airplay.
In today's Mediabase rolling chart, "Stairway" is only the No. 99 most-played Classic Rock song. Last week, it was No. 124. "Sweet Home Alabama," by contrast, is #3. "We Will Rock You/We Are The Champions," a song that has long sported massive burn (despite being well-liked) is #19.
There are lots of reasons that "Stairway" gets less airplay than might otherwise go to a song that tops the music test. It's long. It's slow. There are too many other Led Zeppelin songs in rotation, guaranteeing that no one Zep song is pounded. And it is perceived by PDs as ferociously played-out.
So because the audience never has a chance to get tired of "Stairway to Heaven," the audience never entirely gets tired of it. It's not unlike the late '90s/early '00s where a lot of the most potent Top 40 songs were records like Stereo MC's' "Connected" and Pras Michel's "Ghetto Supastar" that weren't massive currents, but received more recurrent airplay. So if programmers really wanted to be free of "Stairway To Heaven," all they would have do is power it.
In recent years, the approach of the Bob- and Jack-FMs has been to treat everything as if it's "Stairway To Heaven": "Sweet Home Alabama" gets four spins a week and so, in certain weeks, can "Tenderness" by General Public. But now, in the PPM era, a few Jack stations have upped their spins by at least a few each week, while WJMK Chicago is playing its hits 10 times a week or more.
So is there a way that Classic Rock radio could manage all its Mt. Rushmore records to keep them fresh and remain hit-driven enough? Some songs, "Old Time Rock & Roll" and "Hurts So Good" come to mind, receive less Classic Rock airplay than "Stairway To Heaven" and still show signs of perma-burn. But what will keep "(Don't Fear) The Reaper" and "Carry On Wayward Son" fresh and tasty for a while longer?
Reader Comments
Your 2¢, in chronological order — add your comment below.
The other factor I've talked about since consolidation which hurts CURRENT songs is that with the advent of "clusters", stations were discouraged/forbidden from sharing titles which led to not being able to "break" new artists who need multiple stations to establish themselves and not oversaturating the rock libraries in each market. It's not just individual songs but entire libraries have fewer outlets to burn.
Great insight, Sean. Thanks.